Mumbai: India’s influencer marketing industry is undergoing a structural shift as brands build internal capabilities, technology automates routine campaign functions and creators increasingly operate as independent media businesses, according to Ajay Kulkarni, Business Head of Barcode Entertainment.
Agencies Must Move Beyond Transactions
Kulkarni said the growing scale of influencer marketing makes it inevitable that advertisers will seek greater control over creator discovery, outreach and campaign management. Agencies could retain relevance by moving beyond transactional services towards strategic consulting, creator intelligence and large-scale execution.
“Any medium which has grown fast and is operating at scale, brands will want to have that in-house expertise,” he said.
Large campaigns can involve 15,000 to 30,000 creators, requiring considerable coordination. Beyond scale, agencies can differentiate through hyperlocal market knowledge and insights into individual creators.
“The transactional part of influencer marketing, I think, will get automated,” he said.
Creators as Companies
Kulkarni described a convergence between traditional companies seeking cultural relevance and influencers building businesses around their personal brands.
“Companies are trying to become influencers and influencers are trying to become companies,” he said, citing Bhuvan Bam and Kusha Kapila as examples of creators moving beyond conventional endorsements.
“You don’t buy the medium. You buy the audience that it has. Basically, distribution is what you buy,” he added.
From Reach to Revenue
Advertisers are increasingly assessing whether influencer partnerships build the marketing funnel and contribute to sales, rather than evaluating reach alone.
“It’s not about annual partnerships or campaign-wise optimisation. It’s about, am I adding value in terms of building the funnel? Second is driving sales,” Kulkarni said.
He pointed to Coca-Cola’s stated interest in linking creator engagement with product sales. “If that creator is helping the brand to get uplift, then obviously brands will look at investing in that.”
The Fake Engagement Problem
Kulkarni noted fake followers have become easier to identify with analytical tools, but more sophisticated questionable engagement remains harder to evaluate.
He illustrated the disconnect through a supper club he promoted: despite reels generating substantial views and likes, bookings remained weak.
AI and the Identity Question
On AI, Kulkarni drew a key distinction: “There is a significant difference between licensing content and licensing someone’s identity.”
He said AI cannot independently replicate the cultural familiarity, personal credibility and trust that influence consumer behaviour — noting localisation extends beyond language into food, traditions and consumer behaviour.
Usage Rights and Consolidation
Kulkarni said creator agreements require clarity about usage duration and scope. “The first task that we do when we make a deal is to completely understand what the brand is asking for, whether it is one-month usage or two-month usage.”
On consolidation, he was emphatic: “It will happen. 100% it will happen” — adding that acquisition interest would depend on “differentiated capabilities,” not creator network size alone.
Attention Is Not Influence
“There is a difference between attention and influence. They are not the same thing,” Kulkarni said, noting some creators generate visibility through provocative content without delivering credibility.
He also argued for longer-term creator relationships over constantly changing faces, and urged brands to stop treating Instagram like television.
“Please don’t treat Instagram really as a 30-second television commercial. Let it be authentic to storytelling and absolutely raw and real,” he said.
