New York: The creator backlash at this year’s US Open is exposing a broader problem for brands: many are investing heavily in creator activations at major cultural events without clear systems for deciding whom to invite, how to prepare them — or whether the brand even belongs there in the first place.
What Happened
During Naomi Osaka’s first-round match against Anastasia Zakharova, a group of spectators in a luxury suite at Arthur Ashe Stadium began filming a TikTok and making noise mid-match. Chair umpire Kader Nouni paused play and asked them to sit down . In a separate incident, a woman was seen using a bright ring light to take photos of herself during play .
The videos went viral, prompting condemnation from tennis fans and players. Jessica Pegula called the behaviour “a bit disrespectful,” saying: “People are down there trying to perform, and it’s their career and their job” . Naomi Osaka said attendees should “respect the sport” and “read up on the etiquette” .
Crucially, the USTA confirmed that none of the people in the viral videos were among the roughly 100 creators it had officially credentialed — a distinction that was largely lost in the online discourse . The USTA had nearly doubled its creator credentials from 54 in 2025, part of a deliberate strategy to reach new audiences .
Mistake 1: Inviting Without Briefing
The most consistent criticism from creator marketing experts was the absence of proper onboarding. Cayley Stonehouse of Gupta Media told Digiday that a creator brief “should go beyond just deliverables and talking points” to include “the rules of the sport, etiquette, when and where they should be capturing content” .
“This is exactly where the US Open situation could have been flagged early,” said Kate Wolff of Lupine Creative. “A simple objective like ‘capture the moment without disrupting it’ would have gone a long way” .
The comparison experts repeatedly drew was to how journalists are treated. “The PR industry is setting creators up to fail when it does not provide the same level of onboarding, context and guidance that it routinely offers reporters,” wrote Ashley Stoney of Curley Company .
Mistake 2: Treating Creators as Distribution, Not Participants
Becky Owen, CMO of Billion Dollar Boy, said her agency mandates “strict etiquette protocols that protect the craft of the athletes and the experience of paying fans” . The US Open backlash, she suggested, reflected a failure to set those expectations.
Beni Brown of Buttermilk framed the deeper question: “How do we ensure that the gameplay is still the main attraction… rather than the spectacle?” She warned that “if tennis in the US Open turns into a spectacle, you’re going to lose that enthusiast, that always-on loyalist” .
Mistake 3: Entering a Cultural Moment Without Belonging There
Ad Age’s framing points to a third, more fundamental error: brands inserting themselves into events where they have no natural claim. The US Open is a sport steeped in etiquette — silence during play, no movement, no flashes. Inviting creators accustomed to loud, reactive, phone-first content into that environment without adaptation was a structural mismatch, not merely a behavioural one.
The consequences extended beyond the tournament. Wimbledon announced it would deny media accreditation to influencers for its 2027 tournament, citing the US Open disruptions . Two creators, Meg Radice and Audrey Jones, said their credentials were revoked after they posted images of them online .
What Brands Should Do Instead
The consensus among experts was not to abandon creator activations but to execute them better. Recommendations included:
- A pre-event call of at least 15 minutes, followed by a one-page recap document, to set expectations and allow questions
- On-site point people who understand both brand and event culture and can intervene in real time
- Clear boundaries on when filming is inappropriate, without scripting every moment — “if a brand scripts every moment, you lose the reason you hired that creator,” said Sebastian Genta of NextGen Creators
- Vetting for event fit, not just reach
As Stoney put it: “Brands invite them to generate culture, conversation and content, then criticize them when they don’t behave like journalists or longtime patrons. That’s not a creator problem. It’s an expectations problem” .
