Mumbai: Fitness influencers are better positioned to enter exclusive brand partnerships than their counterparts in beauty and fashion, where a crowded advertiser market makes single-brand commitments financially restrictive, according to influencer Shraddha Chhetri.
Chhetri said fitness brands are more likely to expect creators to act as long-term brand ambassadors, given the relatively limited number of competing advertisers in the category. In contrast, beauty and fashion influencers often collaborate with multiple brands, making exclusivity a potentially expensive proposition.
“Because of competition, exclusivity is being asked of creators. But in beauty and fashion, where there are so many brands, it isn’t really happening. You see this more in fitness, where brands expect creators to become brand ambassadors because there are fewer brands,” Chhetri said.
The Appeal of Exclusivity
She argued that exclusivity can be a commercially attractive arrangement in categories with fewer competing brands, particularly when contracts run for three or six months and offer creators guaranteed monthly payments.
“In this industry, there’s no guarantee that you will pay every month. But with exclusive contracts, there is a monthly payment, and from the audience’s perspective, loyalty also remains intact,” she said.
However, Chhetri cautioned that such arrangements could substantially reduce earning opportunities for influencers in beauty and fashion, where working with several competing brands is often central to their business models.
Paying for What Creators Give Up
Chhetri said brands must compensate creators for the business they potentially lose by accepting exclusivity clauses.
“If you’re charging ₹50,000 a month for two reels and the brand is also asking for exclusivity, then charge them ₹70,000 or ₹80,000 for exclusivity,” she said.
Her example represents a 40–60% premium over the original monthly fee, though the actual additional compensation would depend on the creator and agreement.
She also suggested exclusivity is better suited to macro-influencers than micro-creators. For micro-influencers, brands are often more interested in obtaining content for their own promotional use than establishing exclusive relationships.
‘Old-School Ambassador Mindset’
Kalyan Kumar, Co-Founder and CEO of KlugKlug, said exclusivity negotiations have been part of influencer marketing for nearly a decade, particularly when brands engage major creators. However, he questioned whether traditional expectations of brand loyalty make sense in categories where consumers routinely use competing products.
According to Kumar, many brand managers continue to approach influencer collaborations with an old-school celebrity ambassador mindset. He argued that such expectations do not reflect how audiences consume products in everyday categories like beauty, fashion and lifestyle.
Unlike infrequent, high-value purchases such as automobiles, consumers regularly switch between skincare, makeup and fashion brands. Expecting influencers to promote only one brand can therefore appear disconnected from actual consumer behaviour.
Kumar said brands seeking exclusive associations need to make a significantly larger financial commitment rather than expecting loyalty through one-off collaborations — suggesting guarantees of around 10–12 campaigns annually within a specific category to make exclusivity commercially worthwhile.
From Informal Request to Formal Clause
Lakshmi Balasubramanian, Founder of Greenroom, said exclusivity was previously more of an unspoken expectation than a formally negotiated condition.
“There was a time when exclusivity wasn’t really a defined part of influencer marketing conversations. Brands would collaborate with a creator, only to see them post content for a competing brand shortly after,” she said.
As the industry matured, exclusivity increasingly became part of formal commercial negotiations. Balasubramanian said brands now approach it differently depending on product category and campaign objectives: some demand broad restrictions on competing collaborations, others seek exclusivity only for individual campaigns.
Short restrictions lasting one or two weeks may occasionally be accommodated, but longer commitments typically involve additional financial compensation. In categories such as nutrition, food and FMCG, exclusivity periods of one to three months are increasingly being discussed.
The Bottom Line
The contrasting approaches across fitness, beauty and fashion highlight how influencer exclusivity is increasingly shaped by category economics rather than a uniform expectation of brand loyalty.
For fitness influencers, exclusive agreements can provide recurring income and reinforce a creator’s association with a particular brand. For beauty and fashion creators, maintaining relationships with multiple advertisers may remain the more lucrative option.
Industry executives suggest brands looking for sustained influencer loyalty will need to offer guaranteed campaign volumes, clearly defined exclusivity periods, and compensation for competing opportunities creators must forgo.
